Fire And Stone Pizzeria

4.5 (366 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
+(11)

About Fire And Stone Pizzeria

Fire And Stone Pizzeria, located in quaint downtown Chillicothe, Ohio, offers a delightful dining experience centered around open-fire pizza. Renowned for its exceptional flavors, the pizzeria stands out thanks to its unique cooking technique and high-quality ingredients. Customers praise the friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite for families and pizza enthusiasts alike. Dishes like the expertly crafted works pizza and flavorful meatball appetizer showcase the venue's commitment to culinary excellence. Catering to various dietary needs, including gluten-free options, Fire And Stone Pizzeria is not just a meal but a memorable journey into deliciousness.

Reviews (366) 4.5

  • D.J. Park
    Jun 26,2025

    Food was excellent. Open fire Pizza is a unique taste for this area. The service was incredible. Friendly staff. Prices were not bad. A bit loud but not uncomfortable. A great selection of beer, IPAs and wines but would not consider this a bar. Definitely a familyrestaurant.

  • Tanya Kirker
    May 15,2025

    Food is good. Wait is a bit slow, but they were busy. We got a box for leftovers. Going to keep this place on my Return too list.

  • Christopher Allerton
    May 8,2025

    In the very quaint downtown of Chillicothe sits this unassuming pizza shop. I was delighted at the idea that they would be using a live fire pizza oven! I ordered the meatball appetizer and it was phenomenal. It wasn't dense at all, there were a couple of cheeses I tasted and the sauce was amazing. The pizza comes out and doesn't disappoint. I decided on the works pizza. Crispy dough (next time I will ask for well done) the toppings were fresh. Again, the pizza sauce is very well balanced. The sausage was not your typical pizza sausage. It was excellent and very well seasoned. Best pizza in Chillicothe.

  • Meghan Ray
    Apr 27,2025

    One my absolute favorites in our town! I've recently had to switch to a gluten free diet, and they have the BEST gluten free crust! They even bake it in a different oven than the other pizzas which helps cut down on cross contamination. Friendly service and locally owned!

  • Michael Fargo
    Apr 19,2025

    Wonderful little gem tucked away in downtown Chillicothe, Ohio. We stopped in for a quick bite, and were pleasantly surprised to find this old history filled building. There's a huge mural painted on the entire wall from 1882! I spent my time while waiting for the food, just walking back and forth studying the painting. The food was great as well. I started with the meatballs as an appetizer...They were excellent with a little bit of spiciness! Then I ordered The Forager with sauteed wild mushrooms, arugula, caramelized onion with roasted garlic white sauce, fontina and house cheese . Excellent choice! I will definitely get the same thing the next time I'm in town.

  • Edward Malec
    Apr 4,2025

    If it means anything, I was born and raised in NYC, pizza capital of the universe...so, anyway, I like pizza!!! I also own a pizza restaurant in Michigan which we joked about with the cook for all of the obvious reasons. I LOVED this pizza and would like to replicate it in my own place. I think it was the sauce that set it apart. It is a 10 in my book. If they threw a price of oak in that oven I think it would be a 12!!! Waitress and cook were friendly and attentive. Don’t care about the price cause it was well worth it ( but the price was good:) Thanks for a great experience on our trek from Florida back to Michigan!!! U guys rock!!!!

  • TONYA SIOUX
    Mar 25,2025

    Excellent Food Atmosphere and Service.

  • Jane's Homemade Goodness
    Mar 24,2025

    Went as soon as they open on a Saturday. Was not busy. Staff was very friendly. I have no complaints on the food. The price was a bit high but I would gladly go back. I really enjoyed the Mediterranean salad and forager pizza.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What popular dishes should I try at Fire And Stone Pizzeria?

    Many diners rave about the open fire pizzas, especially the meatball appetizer and The Forager pizza with mushrooms and caramelized onions.

  • Do I need a reservation, or can I walk in?

    You can definitely walk in; it's a casual spot, but it can get busy during dinner hours.

  • What dining options are available at the restaurant?

    You can choose to dine in, takeout, or enjoy outdoor seating when the weather is nice.

  • What is the atmosphere like, and when is the best time to visit?

    The atmosphere is cozy and trendy with a historic touch, making it a great spot for both casual lunches and lively dinners.

  • What amenities does Fire And Stone Pizzeria offer for families and groups?

    The restaurant is family-friendly, offering high chairs and a spacious seating area, making it great for groups.

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
Wauseon Rollercade

340 W Leggett St, Wauseon, OH 43567, United States

Pizza restaurant
Bella's Pizza

3858 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43228, United States

Pizza restaurant
Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop

223 Broad St, Conneaut, OH 44030, United States

pizza restaurant
Porky's Pizza Trof - Oak Harbor, OH

4811 State Rte 2, Oak Harbor, OH 43449, United States

Pizza restaurant
Larry's Pizza & Wings

36 S London St, Mt Sterling, OH 43143, United States

Pizza restaurant
Belleria Struthers

1010 Youngstown-Poland Rd, Struthers, OH 44471, United States

Pizza restaurant
Fallsburg Pizza Your Frazeysburg Connection

338 W 3rd St, Frazeysburg, OH 43822, United States

Pizza restaurant
Carmen's Pizza

1861 Youngstown Rd SE, Warren, OH 44484, United States

Pizza restaurant
M & S Carry Out

590 Georgesville Rd, Columbus, OH 43228, United States

Pizza restaurant
Downtown Pizza Mingo Junction

519 Commercial St, Mingo Junction, OH 43938

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page